Aaron Reitz, the top federal prosecutor for the Southern District of Texas, sent Sen. Elizabeth Warren a letter on Sunday telling her to save her records and warning that failing to do so “may result in sanctions … or other penalties,” the Daily Beast reported. Warren does not take over the Senate Banking Committee until January. What drew the warning was her promise to investigate people who cheated Americans. Reitz built his threat on two criminal civil rights laws. Read those laws, and the Constitution, and the threat points the other way.
What the letter says
“In sum, you appear eager to wield your future gavel like a tomahawk, hunting for the scalps of President Trump’s private associates,” Reitz wrote, per the Daily Beast. The letter tells her that “any investigation you and your Senate Democrat colleagues launch from the majority must have a legitimate legislative purpose,” and gives her until 6 p.m. Eastern on Nov. 23 to confirm in writing that she received it and kept everything, UPI reported.
Stephen Miller, the White House chief of staff, reposted it with one line: “18 USC 241 and 242,” Newsweek reported.
Two things set this off. On Face the Nation on Nov. 8, Warren said, “If you’ve been making your profits by cheating American families and scamming your investors, you better get ready for some investigations, serious ones,” according to Newsweek. Then on Nov. 11, Warren, Sen. Richard Blumenthal of Connecticut and Rep. Robert Garcia of California wrote to Meredith O’Rourke, Trump’s top fundraiser, after reports that she coordinated more than $800 million in contributions for the White House ballroom and other Trump projects, UPI reported. The lawmakers say that money “reeks of potential corruption,” per the Daily Beast.
Warren is the fourth Democrat warned in less than a week. Some early reports said Reitz also wrote Garcia. UPI’s account sorts it out: Reitz wrote Blumenthal first, then Sen. Elissa Slotkin of Michigan, then Warren. Garcia’s letter came from White House counsel Will Scharf.
What the two laws say
Section 241 makes it a crime when “two or more persons conspire to injure, oppress, threaten, or intimidate any person” in the “free exercise or enjoyment of any right or privilege secured to him by the Constitution or laws of the United States.” The penalty runs up to ten years in prison.
Section 242 covers anyone who, “under color of any law,” willfully deprives a person of “any rights, privileges, or immunities secured or protected by the Constitution or laws of the United States.” In plain terms: an official who uses the power of his government job to take away someone’s rights.
Reitz’s theory, UPI reported, is that Warren’s investigations could violate Americans’ right to associate with Trump. The letter does not accuse her of breaking any law. A preservation demand “is not a subpoena or court order and does not charge one with any crime,” Newsweek noted.
Of the two people in this exchange, only one holds a federal prosecutor’s office and is using it to warn the other of penalties for what she said and wrote.
The clause that protects her
Members of Congress, Article I, Section 6 says, “for any speech or debate in either House, they shall not be questioned in any other place.”
The Supreme Court has already tested Reitz’s argument. In Eastland v. United States Servicemen’s Fund in 1975, a group sued to block a Senate subcommittee from subpoenaing its bank records, claiming the First Amendment protected its associations. The Court ruled for the senators. “The power to investigate and to do so through compulsory process plainly falls within that definition,” Chief Justice Warren Burger wrote, and the clause’s protections are “absolute.” The Court’s summary adds that “the motives alleged to have prompted it are not to be considered.”
That is the same “legitimate legislative” test Reitz quotes back at Warren. Investigating where $800 million went and whether donors got favors for it is the job the clause protects.
What comes next
Reitz’s deadline is Nov. 23. Warren had not responded as of Monday morning, the Daily Beast reported. Garcia, expected to chair the House Oversight Committee in January, told NPR last week, “We’re not going to be deterred, and we’re certainly not going to be intimidated by Donald Trump or anyone in the administration,” per Newsweek.
Section 242 is one paragraph long. Read it, then read the letter.
The law Reitz cited was written for officials who use their office to scare people away from their rights, and he mailed it to the wrong address.