The White House’s top lawyer has told the incoming House Democrats that some of their investigations “may cross the line into blatant criminality.” The Constitution and the Supreme Court draw the line somewhere else. A member of Congress cannot be prosecuted for the work of investigating: the hearing, the subpoena, the questions asked in committee. A member can be prosecuted for a crime that sits outside that work, like taking a bribe. Democrats won control of Congress this month and take over in January.

What the White House said

White House counsel Will Scharf wrote to Rep. Robert Garcia of California, the top Democrat on the House Oversight Committee and its likely next chairman, in a letter dated Monday, Nov. 9, the Associated Press reported. Scharf wrote that “threats to executive branch officials designed to deter them from public service, or process designed merely to abuse or instill fear in the recipient may cross the line into blatant criminality.”

He also wrote that “The Administration will not be extorted and will not be cowed,” per Democracy Docket. The letter made clear the White House would fight subpoenas it says lack a “legitimate legislative purpose,” The Washington Post reported, and the counsel’s office has added 15 hires so far.

On Saturday, The New York Times reported that Trump “has embarked on an even more aggressive maneuver: threatening to treat some legislative oversight as a potential crime.” The Times added that he “has also become increasingly concerned that some of his biggest supporters who give money toward his prized construction projects will be targeted.” Those donors are already on the list: Sen. Richard Blumenthal of Connecticut has asked donors to the White House ballroom, including Palantir and Lockheed Martin, to start producing records by Nov. 30, the Post reported.

Garcia’s answer, via the AP: “it appears Donald Trump has something to hide.” Congress’s power, he said, does not need the “permission of the White House.”

What the Constitution says

Article I, Section 6 says members of Congress are “privileged from Arrest” while Congress is in session, except for “Treason, Felony and Breach of the Peace.” Then comes the Speech or Debate Clause: “for any Speech or Debate in either House, they shall not be questioned in any other Place,” the text reads. In plain words, no prosecutor and no court gets to punish a lawmaker for doing a lawmaker’s job.

What the Supreme Court says

In 1927, in McGrain v. Daugherty, the Court held that “the power of inquiry,” backed by the power to force answers, “is an essential and appropriate auxiliary to the legislative function.” In other words, investigating is part of making laws. The case grew out of a Senate investigation of the Justice Department under Attorney General Harry Daugherty.

In 1975, in Eastland v. United States Servicemen’s Fund, the Court said a Senate subpoena fell inside the “sphere of legitimate legislative activity,” and that the clause’s protection is “absolute.” It called the power of inquiry “an integral part of the legislative process.”

The shield has an edge. In 1972, in United States v. Brewster, the Court let the bribery prosecution of a former senator go forward: “Taking a bribe is, obviously, no part of the legislative process or function; it is not a legislative act.”

Congress has limits too. In Trump v. Mazars, decided 7-2 in 2020, the Court said a subpoena must be “related to, and in furtherance of, a legitimate task of the Congress,” that Congress may not subpoena for “law enforcement,” and that “there is no congressional power to expose for the sake of exposure.” Scharf cited Mazars in his letter, Democracy Docket reported. Mazars was a lawsuit over subpoenas, not a prosecution. The justices sent the subpoenas back to lower courts to weigh.

What this means for you

Democrats plan to look at the ballroom and other construction projects, the Trump family’s role in mineral deals and Trump’s crypto dealings, the AP reported. Those are questions about who paid, what they got and whether the rules need changing. The rulings above say asking them is Congress’s job, and a court, not a prosecutor, decides when a subpoena goes too far. BTP covers a separate U.S. attorney’s letter to Sen. Elizabeth Warren in its own story.

Watch the January subpoenas, and watch who answers them.