Howard Lutnick's Commerce Department sat for months on blacklisting Megaspeed, the Nvidia buyer Washington suspects of moving chips to China, and a Republican senator now says Lutnick "used loopholes to allow some of these chip sales."
Sen. Jim Banks of Indiana, a member of the Senate Banking Committee, told Fox News on Thursday, Nov. 12: "Secretary Lutnick, it appears, used loopholes to allow some of these chip sales to occur even though President Trump has directed his administration and the Department of Commerce not to allow that to happen." CBS News reported the remark on Nov. 13, along with this: "A growing number of Republicans are calling on Lutnick to answer questions" about the delay in adding Singapore-based Megaspeed International to the Entity List, "which would have restricted the company's ability to get access to advanced AI chips."
Four departments said yes. Commerce held the pen.
Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent put the blame on Commerce in a CNBC interview. As CBS quoted him: "Treasury, War, [the U.S. Trade Representative] and State, they were in favor of putting Megaspeed on the Entity List for months, but Commerce has the pen." AP's account via PBS paraphrases the same interview with "State and Defense"; War and Defense name the same department. Bessent also said: "I am frustrated when President Trump made it very clear China should not receive any Nvidia chips above H100s."
Who ran Megaspeed
CBS reports Megaspeed "was previously led by Alice Huang, the suspected Chinese spy who had an affair with Jensen Huang," and that "the U.S. government suspects Megaspeed of directing advanced Nvidia chips to China, circumventing a U.S. export ban." That is suspicion; no charge has been reported. Jensen Huang resigned as Nvidia's CEO on Nov. 12 after news of the affair, and U.S. intelligence suspects Alice Huang is a Chinese spy, according to The New York Times as relayed by AP. AP also relays the Times report that Lutnick "resisted placing greater limits on the sale of Nvidia's more advanced chips to China" and "has come under increasing scrutiny because of his reportedly close relationship with Huang."
The other side
Megaspeed said in December it found "no evidence" of illicit exports, and on Nov. 12 said it takes export-control compliance "extremely seriously." Bessent declined to comment on reported tensions with Lutnick. Commerce did not respond to CBS or AP. One explanation for the delay is interagency process or a trade-talks hold before Trump's China visit rather than a favor to Nvidia. No record reviewed for this story shows money moving to Lutnick in connection with the delay.
Dec. 10
Lutnick "has agreed to testify before the Senate Banking Committee on Dec. 10, according to a U.S. official," CBS reports. Export controls exist to keep the most powerful American chips away from a rival's military. When the one office holding the pen sits still while four others push, a company's sales channel stays open and the public carries the risk. The question for Dec. 10 is simple: will Lutnick name, under oath, who decided to keep Megaspeed off the list?