The Court Left the Ballot Rule Blocked. It Didn't Kill It.
One justice who voted to keep it blocked wrote that the rule may fall within the Postal Service's power. His objection was the calendar.
Get the next one in your inbox. Free, every weekday morning.
Burn the Establishment Playbook Est. 2025 · Insider teaser |
Burn the Playbook
“The newsletter DC reads and hopes you don’t.”
★ Independent · Editor-Owned ★
| Morning Edition | Vol. I · Washington | Mon, Oct 12, 2026 |
The Standard Two of three sources. One a document.
The Firewall Economics, never coverage.
![]() The Court · Mail Ballots The issue in three numbers.
|
Inside The story · Polling Desk · Watch BTP · Doing Some Good · Jobs · Reading · Watching |
On Sept. 14, the Supreme Court turned down the Trump administration's emergency request to lift the block on a postal rule that would have let the Postal Service turn away the ballots election offices mail to voters. The order ran three sentences. The one that matters reads: "The Government is unlikely to succeed on the merits of its challenge to the District Court's preliminary injunction."
Take the win. Then read the rule. The rule is final, and it is still there. One of the justices who voted to keep it blocked wrote that it may fall within the Postal Service's power.
Why this still matters after the Sept. 14 order: the rule is blocked, not dead, and the fight over 2028 starts with it already written.
By the Numbers
Two justices, Samuel Alito and Clarence Thomas, dissented from the order keeping the rule blocked, per the Supreme Court order in USPS v. California, Sept. 14, 2026. |
Five data points per mail voter: name, address, outbound envelope barcode, return envelope barcode and originating state, uploaded to a Postal Service portal, per the USPS final rule in the Federal Register, Aug. 26, 2026. |
Roughly 47 million mail ballots in 2024: about 30% of the more than 158 million counted ballots, by our math on EAC figures, per the U.S. Election Assistance Commission, June 30, 2025. |
100 North Carolina county boards were set to begin mailing absentee ballots Sept. 4, before the Court ruled, per the N.C. State Board of Elections, Sept. 2, 2026. |
12 states supported the rule in the lower court and asserted that compliance at this time was practicable, per Justice Alito's dissent in the Supreme Court order, Sept. 14, 2026. |

Ad. BTP may earn a commission if you sign up. Thinking about working for yourself? Inc Authority says it will register your LLC free, and you pay only the required state fees. Start your LLC → |
The power sat at the post office counter
The rule carries out a March 31 executive order from President Trump. Under it, any state that votes by mail would have had to upload the name, address and two unique barcodes for every mail voter to a Postal Service portal, and print a unique barcode on every outgoing and return ballot envelope. The rule says the Postal Service will not check those names against voter rolls.
The check that mattered was the barcode check at the counter. If a mailing failed it, the rule says it "will not be accepted and will be returned" to the election office, which has to fix the errors and bring it back. The Postal Service calls that a temporary rejection. In the weeks when ballots go out, I call it a delay no county can afford.
That counter check covers ballots going out to voters. It does not apply to the completed ballot you send back.
Who stopped it
The order the Supreme Court left standing is Judge Indira Talwani's Sept. 4 preliminary injunction in the District of Massachusetts, which blocks the rule nationwide, the Boston Globe reported. More than 20 states and the District of Columbia, led by California, sued.
Talwani had already drawn the line on Aug. 11, ruling on the executive order behind all of this: "The executive branch has no authority to regulate elections." In Washington, a Trump appointee, Judge Carl Nichols, blocked the rule too, the National Association of Counties reported Sept. 15. He found it went beyond the Postal Service's general rulemaking power.
Take the win. Then read the rule. |
Read the concurrence before you celebrate
Justice Brett Kavanaugh concurred in the denial and wrote separately to explain his vote. He sees "at least a fair prospect that the final rule falls within the Postal Service's statutory authority." But, he wrote, "applying the rule in the 2026 elections would be arbitrary and capricious in violation of the Administrative Procedure Act because state and local election officials do not have sufficient time to reasonably implement the rule before the elections."
Give him credit: he took the people who run elections seriously. But he did not call the rule lawless. He called it late, and late runs out after Nov. 3.
In dissent, Alito wrote that some plaintiffs lacked standing and the rest were pursuing a claim that "this Court has recently called a 'Hail Mary pass' that 'rarely succeeds.'" For now, the pass was completed. This was an emergency order, not a final ruling on the rule.
If you vote by mail
The courts have this rule blocked, so it cannot touch your ballot this November as things stand. Request your ballot, fill it out, and mail it back early. Check your own state's deadlines with your election office. In North Carolina, requests close at 5 p.m. on Oct. 20, and completed ballots must be received by 7:30 p.m. on Nov. 3 (military and overseas voters have later deadlines).
The dangerous stretch comes after a win, once everyone else stops reading. The coverage has moved on. I haven't. Here is what I see: a rule still in the Federal Register, and a concurrence that turned on a calendar.
Forward this to one person who votes by mail, so they hear it from you before they hear a rumor. |
Polling Desk Do voters trust the mail?Published polls only, each with its method on the label, so you can judge the number yourself. NPR/PBS News/Marist · National poll 58% of registered voters trust the Postal Service to deliver election mail to voters and election officials on time, down from 71% in 2024. Pollster: Marist Poll Most voters still trust the mail with their ballot, but 13 points fewer than in 2024. A rule that puts a barcode check between your ballot and the mail would land on that smaller base of trust. |
Watch · BTP From the BTP channel![]() One Bad Barcode, 10,000 Ballots Back. His Own Judges Shut It. Burn the Playbook on YouTube · Watch it ![]() Supreme Court Asked to Rule on Postal Service Voting Changes Burn the Playbook on YouTube · Watch it |
Spotlight Doing Some GoodOne person each issue making life better for the people around them.
Roxanne Gerads Elections supervisor · Stearns County, Minn. Roxanne Gerads has run elections for Stearns County, Minnesota, for 27 years, through new technology, population growth and changing state and federal rules, KNSI reports. In May, Secretary of State Steve Simon gave her the Minnesota Excellence in Elections Award, which recognized her guidance and support for city and township election officials, WJON reports. Sources: KNSI, May 8, 2026; WJON, May 11, 2026 |
Jobs Board Who’s hiringOpenings across four lanes, each link checked Oct. 3. Pay is what the employer posts. Jobs can close without notice, so check the listing before you apply. Public service Office of Sen. Alex Padilla · Washington, D.C. Pay: Not posted Entry level. Spanish is a plus. Senate Employment Bulletin listing. Unions and nonprofits Senior Field Representative, Political and Field Mobilization Hub AFL-CIO · Central Region field role: IA, IL, IN, KS, MI, MN, MO, ND, NE, OH, SD or WI, within 100 miles of a major airport Pay: $108,394.48 a year Listed on the Union Jobs Clearinghouse; applications go through the AFL-CIO. Law Fellowship Lawyer, Legal Department (starts September 2027) AFL-CIO Office of the General Counsel · Washington, D.C. Pay: $89,590.88 a year Recent law graduates, judicial clerks and third-year law students may apply. Listed on the Union Jobs Clearinghouse. Any field HighLevel · Remote, open only to residents of 18 states: AZ, CA, FL, ID, IL, MD, MI, NC, NJ, NV, NY, OR, PA, SC, TN, TX, VA, WA. Some travel. Pay: $44,000 to $50,000 a year Asks for 1 to 3 years in sales support, account coordination or administrative sales. |
Reading Things Mike Is ReadingProPublica The FBI Anti-Corruption Squad Was Circling Susan Collins, Until Trump Got in the Way ProPublica reports what Martin Kao, then CEO of the defense contractor Navatek, later told the FBI: that money for a pro-Collins super PAC was tied to Navy contracts. Those are allegations, not charges. Collins' office “vigorously” denies them and calls them “outlandish,” and the FBI says it investigated years ago and “ultimately found nothing implicating Senator Collins.” William Turton, Avi Asher-Schapiro, Molly Redden and Kirsten Berg · Sept. 22, 2026 |
Watching Things Mike Is Watching![]() LegalEagle · Oct. 2 A lawyer's walk through the bribery allegations against Sen. Susan Collins. They are allegations, not charges, and her office denies them. ![]() Some More News · Sept. 23 Why These Flock Cameras Are Worse Than You Thought An episode on Flock license-plate cameras and the data they collect. |
Ad. BTP may earn a commission if you subscribe. Five minutes, then back to your day. Five Minute Daily says it covers the whole day's news in five minutes. BTP goes deep on one story each issue, while Five Minute Daily is for the quick sweep of the rest. Try Five Minute Daily free → |
Sources
Supreme Court of the United States, order, concurrence and dissent in USPS v. California, No. 26A305, Sept. 14, 2026.
Federal Register, U.S. Postal Service final rule, "Ballot Mail for Federal Elections," 91 FR 54966, published Aug. 26, 2026, effective Aug. 21, before its publication, per the Federal Register.
U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts, memorandum and order, League of Women Voters of Massachusetts v. Trump, Aug. 11, 2026.
Boston Globe, on the Sept. 4 preliminary injunction, Sept. 4, 2026.
National Association of Counties, on the Supreme Court order and the Nichols injunction, Sept. 15, 2026.
U.S. Election Assistance Commission, 2024 Election Administration and Voting Survey release, June 30, 2025.
North Carolina State Board of Elections, release on 2026 absentee ballot mailing, Sept. 2, 2026.
Burn Notice: One justice's vote turned on the calendar. Nothing in the order saves 2028.
Michael
This one is built to forward.
Subscribe free to get the next briefing in your inbox.




